Can Gaining Weight Contribute to an Eating Disorder?

PsycoFit · Psychology of Fitness
You’ve been trying to lose weight for a while, and the scale keeps going up. Your clothes feel different. You’re frustrated because you’ve been putting in effort and still feel like you have very little say in what your body does.
Then you find yourself searching for something more drastic. A few weeks ago, you might have dismissed it. Now you’re reading the whole page. Part of you knows it could be dangerous. Another part is thinking, What else am I supposed to do?
Weight gain alone doesn’t establish why someone develops an eating disorder. For some people, distress about gaining weight can contribute to a pattern of restrictive eating, feeling out of control around food, or exercising to compensate for eating. Eating disorders arise from a combination of factors and can affect people at any weight. National Institute of Mental Health
How can weight gain contribute?
Imagine two people whose weight changes by the same amount. One feels irritated when their jeans get tighter and gets on with their day. The other starts thinking about their weight when they wake up, while they eat, and when they decide whether they’re allowed to rest. The scale shows the same change. The second person is carrying a much heavier burden throughout the day.
In one study, researchers followed 496 adolescent girls for eight years. Body dissatisfaction predicted a higher likelihood of later eating-disorder symptoms or diagnoses. The researchers also found a different pattern involving dieting among girls who reported less body dissatisfaction. Because the study followed adolescents, it can’t tell us how likely any particular adult is to develop an eating disorder after gaining weight. It does show that these problems can develop in several ways. Stice and colleagues, eight-year study
Pressure from others can add to the distress. A relative comments on what’s on your plate. Someone tells you how much better you looked before. You start dreading seeing people who haven’t seen you in a while because you’re waiting for them to say something. A 2024 review of 242 studies found a consistent association between weight stigma and disordered eating thoughts and behaviours. The review couldn’t establish what caused any one person’s symptoms. Levinson and colleagues, review of weight stigma and disordered eating
What does losing control actually mean?
The first feeling is being unable to change your weight. You put in effort, expect a result, and feel increasingly frustrated when it doesn’t happen. A promise of fast results starts to sound tempting when you’re tired of hoping something will work.
The second feeling is being unable to stop or control your eating once you start. That can be upsetting, especially if it happens repeatedly or leaves you feeling ashamed. It’s a symptom clinicians ask about when assessing binge eating. A recurring feeling of losing control around food is worth discussing with someone who understands eating disorders. NIDDK guide to binge eating disorder
Those feelings can feed into each other. You feel frustrated about your weight and respond by becoming stricter about food. Later, you feel out of control around eating, and the next morning you feel pressure to be even stricter. For some people, restrictive dieting can contribute to binge eating. That helps explain why doubling down can make food feel harder to manage. NIDDK on risk factors
When drastic measures start to sound reasonable
The shift can be gradual. You start by thinking, I’d like my clothes to feel more comfortable. Later it becomes, I need this weight off as fast as possible. Then you find yourself considering something you’d feel worried about if a friend told you she was doing it.
As a fitness instructor, I think the language we use around exercise matters here. You might enjoy Body Sculpt because you feel stronger or because you like the people in class. If you start feeling you have to exercise to make up for what you ate, or feel unable to take a rest day even when you’re exhausted, that’s a change worth noticing. Clinicians consider excessive exercise used to compensate for eating when they assess eating disorders. NICE eating disorder guidance
It’s worth paying attention when:
- Thoughts about food, weight, or shape take up more and more of your day.
- Your food rules are getting stricter, or you’re avoiding meals with other people because eating feels stressful.
- You repeatedly feel unable to stop or control your eating.
- You feel driven to exercise to make up for eating, or you’re considering weight-loss methods you believe might harm you.
Do you have to look a certain way to ask for help?
No. People can experience an eating disorder while gaining weight, losing weight, or staying around the same weight. Clinical guidance says that a single measure such as BMI should never decide whether someone is offered treatment. How much distress you’re experiencing and what’s happening with your eating and exercise matter. NICE guidance on assessment and referral
If this sounds familiar, you can start by telling a healthcare professional what has changed. You could say, “I’m getting so frustrated about my weight that I’ve started looking at things I know might be dangerous,” or “I’m having times when I feel like I can’t stop eating, and it’s upsetting me.” You can ask for support now, especially if you’re already taking risks or feel close to doing so. NIMH on treatment and support
Keep reading in the follow-up: What to Do When Food, Weight, and Exercise Start to Feel Out of Control. We’ll look at what you can do in the moment, how to talk about what’s happening, and where to find support.
